Apparently, despite this having been explained to you ad nauseum, you still don't get the term. Quick, find where I assigned a tought to you that wasn't what you said in that particular post. You can't, because it isn't there. Therefore, not a strawman. Do this analysis, where you look to see if someone has misrepresented what you said, each time you want to use the term "strawman".
Backup catchers are all pretty much the same. Good on the defensive side, usually better behind the plate than the starter, and pretty weak with the bat. It's clear that I'm talking about the similarity between Flaherty and Molina in this regard. You are taking the terms literally, when common sense would see this is what I'm doing (as I've mentioned before, you lack this trait, so having to explain this is no surprise). Flaherty doesn't identify with the type of player Posada is, so no, if he were arbitrarily made the backup against convention, Flaherty wouldn't be giving him hyperbolic praise.
You are like the little engine that couldn't. I'll give you some credit trying to draw a comparable situation there, but in typical fashion, common sense elluded you, and you were wrapped in the cold embrace of failure.