I'd slip Brady in at fifth, at the highest.
I'd have Elway, Montana, Marino, Manning ahead of him... by quite a bit, for now.
The way Manning has bent you over, wouldn't you agree? Like I said, it's not his fault Marvin Harrison had to wear Ty Law as a winter jacket one game. Besides, that was a speed and timing based offense playing in the cold and snow against a team built to win in those conditions.
Manning sees the game the way that no other player ever has. His preparation is just incredible. And his arm's as good as anyone's. The guy's insane. He's the best ever. He's done it for long enough that he's the best ever.