I don't think I'm getting carried away. I think that we're talking about a guy who has regularly been injured and hasn't put together a full healthy season. I stated honestly that he doesn't have the power, but his plate control and ability to make hard contact is very, very good.
Production-wise, very few hitters can rival what Manny has done. As far as pure talent and ability to hit a thrown ball I think JD Drew has shown that he's among the elite. Clearly the Sox thought so, that's why they paid him as much as they did. Look at his control and calm there at the plate.
Regardless, I'm very excited to have him as the #5 on this team.