If your offense regularly scores 1 or 2 or 3 runs in a game it doesn't matter how good the pitching is. The pitching on this team is deep enough when Schilling comes back and with the possibility of a guy like Buchholz coming up to help from the pen. Most of the players I've heard talked about are essentially Joel Pineiro but on other teams. There are a few who would likely be more than just consistent .500 pitchers, but not enough to put a whole lot of prospects or money into. People were advocating to sell the farm for Barry Zito last year and would likely do the same this year if he didn't totally s*** the bed. The point is that decent pitchers are around and pitchers often considered "good" can give up bombs and 7 ER starts just like Tavarez and Wakefield and Igawa and Mussina. Gabbard, Hansack, Snyder, Pineiro, Lester are all options.
The issue is that there is no chemistry in the offense. People are batting all over the place, Drew is leading off, no, wait it's Crisp, no, Lugo, Pedroia, you want a shot? Youkilis. The only guys who don't move are Manny and Papi, and I think that should change too, except for the L,R,L thing. There is no power from the 3/4 spots and even LESS than no power from the 5 spot. Youkilis does his darndest, but he's just not a HR hitter. Drew is supposed to be driving the ball, but he hasn't been and doesn't look like he's capable of it. Lowell is decent, Tek is a good hitting catcher all things considered, Lugo and Crisp are turning it around. The pieces are there, but there just isn't that 'click'.