I agree. Youkilis likely scores on that ball too, but Manny or Ortiz are standing at 3rd.
That said, a pathetic, a FREAKING pathetic way to lose a game for the Mets. Weak. Should be a 3 game lead for the Sox.
Someone should see if Castillo had a bet on the Yankees winning the game or something. MLB 2Bs just don't make that error, and certainly not in that situation. In reality it is a tough play (a MLB pop-up, and A-Rod really popped it up) but that's an excuse (on a very limited basis) for a GCL player, not an MLB regular.