Here is what I would do.
-Not trade Mussina, a lot of people want to trade Mussina, but what he brings to the rotations when healthy and on his game is unparralled. He is not a power pitcher, but will get you with his craftiness. A lot of Yankee rotations over his tenure have based on power, he is the opposite and having him in the middle of the rotation helps, especially with his pitches. He has the best knuckle-curve in baseball and throws great breaking stuff. So I say keep him.
-Bring Tanyon Sturtze and Aaron Small into spring training to compete with each other, and whoever has the worse Spring Training I would trade for a prospect or 2. I dont think there is room on this team for both of them with the number of pitchers we have.
-Not sign Damon for anymore than 3 years. If he wants more, then screw him, I am content with Bernie and Bubba holding down Center Field next year keeping it hot for Melky.
-Do not trade Melky Cabrera. Everyone wants to trade him after his stint with the Yankees last year, But I have a great feeling about him. I think he is going to be the next in the long like of great Yankee center fielders. Watching him play it is appearant he knows what he is doing, he was just a little overwhelmed with his callup last year and wasnt given a fair chance. Remember, Cano struggled for a while at first and went on to be one of the top rookies in all of baseball and earned himself the title of Yankees second basemen for a long time to come. Had they given Melky more than a week I think he would have taken over and patrolled CF for the rest of the season.
NOTE: I know it is hard not trading Melky considering how expandable he is due to the amount of good outfield prospects we have, but I would stick with Melky, and if he fizzles out at least we have insurance. (BTW, Cabrera is doing very well in winterball this year)
-Move Wright to the bullpen. I think he could be the perfect middle relief/long relief/spot starter. He has that power arm and would be perfect for say the 6th inning. Also, not to mention we really have no choice considering there is no spot for him in the pen.
-I would have liked to keep Proctor arouond in the bigs next year, but considering we just got Villone, the numbers likely wont allow it. So I would give him a fair shot at making the squad in Spring Training, but considering he is the one with the option year left he would have to really blow everybody out of the water to get the spot.
-Keep only 11 pitchers, having 12 most of last year was not good for the depth of our bench. Torre usually carries only 11 but due to the excess amount of pitchers we had we were forced to carry 12
-Bring back Bernie, he deserves it and can still provide us with some good play.
-KEEP Pavano. Last year was rough for him and us, but I say we give the guy another year before shipping him away. I always say a player needs 1 year in New York to adjust and not to jusge him based on his performance in his first year if it is bad.
-TRADE FOR ROBBY HAMMOCK. The Diamondbacks have Snyder and Estrada so its not like they wouldnt be willing to move Robby. I want Robby so bad because of his versatility and age. Before he got hurt last spring he was on pace to become the Diamondbacks catcher of the future. Another plus is that he and Randy Johnson are very close (yes, I know we brought in Stinnett to catch Johnson, but I really do not like Stinnett. BUt whatever, im not suggesting we release him because I want 3 players who are capable of catching, especially if Posada is going to get significant DH time this year). Also, the fact that he can serve in the outfield and has experience at 3B also helps. IM sure if needed he could play 2B or 1B in an emergency, but I doubt we would need him for that. I stated before that I want 3 players who are capable of catching, and the fact that Robby can play other positions makes him a great option, because getting a guy who can catch as well as play other positions as your 3rd catcher is much better than signing a guy who only catches to be your 3rd catcher, destroys bench depth.
-If we are unable to get Hammock I say we sign Matt Lecroy or someone else who can catch as well as play other positions (for the reasons mentioned at the end of my Robby Hammock point)
-Bring back Cairo as the utility guy. The reason I want him over Escalone is the fact that he can play the outfield as well, not to mention how much we loved him in 2004. But if we dont get himIm content with Escalona. Having Cairo and Phillips would be fantastic for our bench depth, Phillips can play every infield position and Cairo can play any position besides catcher and pitcher.
-Not sign anybody else who was offered arbitration, that would cost us a draft pick. We need all of our draft picks.
-Not trade any good prospects, only crappy ones if needed. We need to build up our famr system again. The only way I would trade good prospects (im not talking Hughes, Duncan, Melky, etc. Im talking about guys like Sardinha,Clippard, Thompson, etc..) is in a deal for guys like Ichiro, Pujols, Miguel Cabrera, Felix Hernandez (I know those would pretty much never happen, but those are the players I would reserve our good prospects for), or if we need a Jason Schmidt or somebody like that who could have an impact on our team come the trade deadline. But other than that keep our core of good young prospects in tact.
-I would also bring in some veterans on Minor League deals with Spring Training invites for a chance to win a spot, or be a possibly rewarding insurance policy in case of injury. Guys like Ramiro Mendoza, Juan Gonzalez, Travis Lee, Kevin Millar, Rich Aurilia, Hideo Nomo, Shingo Takatsu, James Baldwin, Denny Neagle, Bobby Estalella, Todd Hundley, Joe Beimel, Gabe White, Steve Cox, Mike Matthews, Eduardo Perez, John Franco, Lou COllier, Fernando Vina, Enrique Wilson, Dave Veres, Keiichi Yabu, Seung Song, Danny Graves, Grant Roberts, Jared Sandberg, Ty Wigginton, Rick White, Rickey Henderson, Rey Ordonez, Chris SIngleton, Ruben Rivera, Charles Gipson, Matt Manteii, Michael Coleman, Roger Cedeno, Mike Vento, Dee Brown, or Jason Tyner. OBVIOUSLY not all of them, just a few who would agree to come in on a Minor League deal with a Spring Training invite under the circumstances and offer insurance and veteran leadership for the young guys in camp.
Here is what I have:
Rotation
Johnson
Mussina
Wang
Chacon
Pavano
Bullpen
Wright
Sturtze/Small
Myers
Villone
Farnsworth
Rivera
Catchers
Posada
Stinnett
Hammock
Infield
Giambi
Phillips
Cano
Cairo
Jeter
Rodriguez
Outfield
Matsui
Crosby
Bernie
Sheffield
I know that is only 24, I would save the 25th spot for someone who earns it out of Spring Training. Like a Kevin Reese, Chris Prieto, or Felix Escalona or someone that we bring in on a Minor Legue deal. A guy I would really like to get in on a Minor League deal/ST invite is Dave Matranga (2B/SS/3B ). He played in the Angels organziation last year (his previous 6 years were with the Astros organization, where he actually hit a Home Run in his first Major League at bat) and saw some time in the bigs. Not only because I know him, but also because he is a very hard working player who does all of the little things right. Mike Scioscia said that he reminded him very much of Adam Kennedy.
If you read the whole thing, THANK YOU VERY MUCH, if not, I dont blame you. But that is just the begining of what I would do for the Yankees.