Say what you want about the draft order and whatnot, about how early picks dont always pan out so having the earlier pick isnt always the best, but rather havinf more picks is, because I agree with you 100%
But answer me this. Would you rather have the #28 pick (Yankees original pick, lost to Boston for Johnny Damon) or the #21 pick (from the Phillies for Gordon)? If you say the #28, you are a retard. I am sorry. Moving up our first round pick 7 spots is an improvement regardless of what you say. So I find it comical that you find it comical that we think Cashman has improved out draft situation. Granted, he didnt do a whole hell of a lot, but fact of the matter is its better than before.
Now I know you're going to argue that because of our greedy, evil, horrible front office chose to go and spend money on Damon that we lost out on TWO first round picks, but think about it. What sense does it make to go out and trade Minor League prospects for a Center Fielder when we can sign one, and lose a draft pick. Its not like we have no first round pick, because we have the #21 pick from the Phillies. You would agree that the Yankees need to keep their farm in tact and stable and not go out and trade prospects for proven players. So thats what we did. Wouldnt make much sense to go any other route than JOhnny Damon. So Cashman took into acount more than the draft, he also took into account the fact that any other option would cost us one or two, or maybe three or 4 prospects. Now lets say that we trade 3 prospects for a center fielder and not sign Damon and keep our #28 pick. We would be losing 3 prospects, drafting one, essentially losing two prospects. Why do that when we can just sign Damon, and lose a pick, and keep our 3 prospects.
Yes, of coarse 2 first round picks would be better than one, but when you look at the big picture, bottom line is he kept the farm in tact (with the exception of the Ben Julienel for Ron Villone trade), and improved our first round drafting positon by 7 spots. So regardless of what you say his offseason is more on the positive than it is on the negative. Sorry.