When A-Rod was a prominent player on the Seattle Mariners he was a huge part of their success, mainly in 2000. In 2000 he got his team into the ALCS and almost beat the Yankees by himself. In the 2 games the M's won in that series (1 and 5) Alex had a solo homer in a 2-0 game 1 win and he had the game tying and winning rbi single in a 6-2 game 5 win. He was a huge part of that club and probably made the mistake of leaving a club, that had a good big of young players and veteran players. When he was on the Texas Rangers from 2001 - 2003, he was one of the only players performing on the team, and I think it goes without saying that he did his part. Elsrbueno, I completely agree with you that his contract crippled the financial state of the Rangers, but it wasn't his fault. It was the Rangers choice to give him the enormous contract and even if he wanted to give back some of the money to the club the players union probably wouldn't let him. The only pitcher that they decided to sign was Chan Ho Park, and he was either hurt or extremely ineffective. Last year with the Yankees he had a good regular season, but not by his standards, which just proves how great a player he really is. Last year the Yankees did not have great pitching so the offensive (with Alex being a big part of it) took them to the playoffs. In the first round he was (along with Matsui) the main reason that the Yanks defeated the Twins. In the ALCS he was great (along with every other Yankee) in the first 3 games, but only had 2 rbi's in the final 4 games. I believe that it is unfair to place all the blame on A-Rod because everyone stopped hitting. As for this year, I think you could make a legitimate case for naming him the American League MVP. By the way, I might not be right, but when all the Red Sox fans say they hate A-Rod I think the main reason is that he is a major part of the Yankees, and he has been in "media wars" with several Red Sox players.