It's very hard to read one very long post with multiple elipses. Please try to be more coherent in the future, your points become abnormally clearer by simply using correct grammar and punctuation.
D-Lowe was not our most solid pitcher. Not by a long shot. He was big in the post-season, but if he was actually a "solid" pitcher during the season we wouldn't have had any trouble getting into the playoffs. It was a race until near the end of the season for the final playoff spot, and D-Lowe during the season dragged us down some.
If you think having D-Lowe and Arroyo would keep us in the AL East lead this year, you have another thing coming. Just about everyone went down at the same time and that helped our team crumble towards the beginning of the stretch run to the playoffs. D-Lowe and Arroyo would have been getting lit up in the AL East. You can say whatever you want about his quality starts and whatnot, but once the batters in the NL Central figured him out he was a steaming pile of crap over in Cinci.
The only 2 people that I miss from breaking up the '04 team are Petey and Damon, bar none. Those were mistakes. I swear, if Damon is still hitting at approximately a .290 clip scoring runs like mad for the Yankees in his final year on his contract, that will not settle nicely at all with me. In fact, I almost hope it does happen, because I want the front office to get slapped in the face and learn that they don't mess with talent. You keep it. It's ok though, because this year the FO will be watching Pedro and Damon in the playoffs this year, possibly even facing off in the world series. I can feel the sting on their cheeks already.