I love Youk, I think he's ready NOW. No reason to sign Beltre (for big $$) when you already have a cheap platoon of Mueller/Youk for 05. Then in 06 it's Youk's full-time job.
Keep in mind that Youk will get worse before he gets better, once teams have seen him a second time around. That being said, I think he will adjust, and be a successful MLB regular for the Sox.
MKZ is an awesome player to have around. Keep him please.
Millar's got a decent bat, but he's too one-dimensional. He can't play defense, can't run, bunt, work counts.....
I like having Pokey around. He's got a GREAT glove, and is a VERY valuable player off the bench. He's fast as hell, I wish the Red Sox would run him more. Keep him.
Pedro's a keeper.
I like Nomah555's idea of possibly moving Cabrera to second and resigning him. He's got a great glove, and a good attitude (seems like so far at least). This, of course, ONLY if the Red Sox can sign a guy like Renteria. Otherwise, I say resign Cabrera and keep him at short. Either way, keep Orlando.
Tek: Hardest decision on this list. Shopp doesn't quite seem ready, and Mirabelli every day is a bit of a scary thought. If Tek demands a lot of money, he's got to GO. If he comes back for a reasonable price...sign him to a 1 or 2 year deal (no more than 2).
Williamson might not pitch in 05...So the Sox have no choice but to let him go.
D-Lowe goes unless he comes back for CHEAP.
I think that covers all CURRENT Sox players. What the Sox will need:
Another starting pitcher. With D-Lowe gone, the Sox will need a #3 starter. Wake/Arroyo are solid 4 and 5 guys, but the Sox one more starter to slot into #3 (2 top flight starters if Pedro leaves)
Setup men. Timlin/Embree are struggling, and Williamson's most likely gone. Foulke's done a decent job closing games, but we need people to bridge the gap from starters to Keith.
Shortstop. I like Cabby, but if a deal can be worked for Renteria....I say grab him.