I've been really hard on Terry Francona throughout the season, but I have to admit I don't really disagree with his moves so far.
Schilling said he was ready in game 1. He got Shelled.... the Sox outscored the Yankees 7-4 after Schilling left.
Pedro simply got outpitched in game 2 by Lieber. One COULD argue that he shouldn't have been out there for Olerud...
Game 3 was one of those games where NOTHING worked out. Can hardly be blamed on Francona.
Game 4... It's tough to give D-Lowe the start in an elimination game, but what other options did they have? Taking him out was controversial.... but Timlin made the pitches and the fielders didn't make the plays.
Game 5...Pedro got lit up in his final inning, and he'd been struggling all night... so again, he MIGHT have been left in just a little to long... but Jeter hit a good pitch, is very good in the clutch... and we'd have been in trouble regardless of who pitched.
It was a little weird to have Varitek catching Wakefield...and it made Tek look bad... This is not the decision I'd have made, but I can see why Francona didn't make the move.
Game 6: How can you complain when the Sox WIN? Schilling pitched the perfect amount of innings. Just enough to give the 'pen a good chance to close it out, but not too long. Arroyo dominates righties, and with Cairo,Jeter,Arod,Sheffield up... who'd you rather have in there? Foulke for the 9th was a no-brainer... although if it were me I'd have thrown Myers against Matsui to start it.
Overall, I think it's been a well managed series. You can't really blame any of these games on the managers (IMHO).