I agree. I, and most Red Sox fans, tend to think of Jeter as overrated. Believe me, he is. Yankee fans go to ridiculous lengths to hump their favorite shortstop; some even proclaim him the best player in baseball. (And let it be noted that, even if it may have been used incorrectly, that was the first usage of a colon in a sentence in Talksox history). His career stats tell the tale:
SEASON TEAM G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO SB CS OBP SLG AVG
1995 New York Yankees 15 48 5 12 4 1 0 7 18 3 11 0 0 .294 .375 .250
1996 New York Yankees 157 582 104 183 25 6 10 78 250 48 102 14 7 .370 .430 .314
1997 New York Yankees 159 654 116 190 31 7 10 70 265 74 125 23 12 .370 .405 .291
1998 New York Yankees 149 626 127 203 25 8 19 84 301 57 119 30 6 .384 .481 .324
1999 New York Yankees 158 627 134 219 37 9 24 102 346 91 116 19 8 .438 .552 .349
2000 New York Yankees 148 593 119 201 31 4 15 73 285 68 99 22 4 .416 .481 .339
2001 New York Yankees 150 614 110 191 35 3 21 74 295 56 99 27 3 .377 .480 .311
2002 New York Yankees 157 644 124 191 26 0 18 75 271 73 114 32 3 .373 .421 .297
2003 New York Yankees 119 482 87 156 25 3 10 52 217 43 88 11 5 .393 .450 .324
2004 New York Yankees 154 643 111 188 44 1 23 78 303 46 99 23 4 .352 .471 .292
2005 New York Yankees 84 341 69 105 12 2 11 37 154 41 57 10 4 .393 .452 .308
Career Totals 1450 5854 1106 1839 295 44 161 730 2705 600 1029 211 56 .386 .462 .314
With a career average nearing .315, it's almost a given that he'll eventually get into the hall provided he keeps it up, especially with the pressure that would be coming out of New York. He may not, however, be a first ballot hall of famer. That distinction should be reserved for the best of the best, players who without a doubt represent the epitome of baseball awesomeness, of which there were only a few playing in last night's game.
edit: the formatting seems to be royally effed in that code snippet, but you get the point.