Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
Schaub over Rivers' date=' Peyton or Brady? I don't think so.[/quote']

 

you can make the case for Schaub over Brady

 

Brady : 4212 passing yards , 28TD, 12INT , 97.4 QB rating

Schaub: 4467 passing yards, 27TD, 14 INT , 99.1 QB rating

Posted
you can make the case for Schaub over Brady

 

Brady : 4212 passing yards , 28TD, 12INT , 97.4 QB rating

Schaub: 4467 passing yards, 27TD, 14 INT , 99.1 QB rating

 

QB rating is the NFL equivalent to RBI's, dude. You can use it as a support statistic, and little more. However, your point is valid, they're comparable players, just don't think Schaub is better than Manning at all. No one is.

Posted
you can make the case for Schaub over Brady

 

Brady : 4212 passing yards , 28TD, 12INT , 97.4 QB rating

Schaub: 4467 passing yards, 27TD, 14 INT , 99.1 QB rating

 

Maybe you can. I certainly can't.

Posted
QB rating is the NFL equivalent to RBI's' date=' dude. You can use it as a support statistic, and little more. However, your point is valid, they're comparable players, just don't think Schaub is better than Manning at all. No one is.[/quote']

 

Manning is the starter. Brady and Rivers the backups.

Schaub is having a good season, almost as good as Brady's. But not quite.

Posted

How do you forget about Alex Mack? Look at these stats:

 

Year Team G GS Pen Yds False Start Holding Sacks Allwd Yds

2009 Cle 15 15 1 6 0 0 0.25 1.75

Totals 15 15 1 6 0 0 0.25 1.75

 

Year-2009-Totals

Team-Cle

Games-15-15

Games Started-15-15

Penalty-1-1

Yards-6-6

False Start-0-0

Holding-0-0

Sacks Allowed-0.25-0.25

Yards-1.75-1.75

 

I tried to make it easier for you to read.

Joe Thomas got into the pro bowl with 6 sacks this year.

Posted
Similar TD's, similar INT's, similar passing yardage. QB rating is worthless, really, it's even worse than RBI's or batting average. I think there's a case, but I think there's a case for Brett Favre's too. Comparable yardage, best INT% in football, comparable TD's (edges them both out, actually) and if we're actually going to use the stat, which we shouldn't, he has a higher QB rating.
Posted
Manning is the starter. Brady and Rivers the backups.

Schaub is having a good season, almost as good as Brady's. But not quite.

 

He's having a comparable season, the stats say so. It's really too close to call.

Posted
How do you forget about Alex Mack? Look at these stats:

 

Year Team G GS Pen Yds False Start Holding Sacks Allwd Yds

2009 Cle 15 15 1 6 0 0 0.25 1.75

Totals 15 15 1 6 0 0 0.25 1.75

 

Year-2009-Totals

Team-Cle

Games-15-15

Games Started-15-15

Penalty-1-1

Yards-6-6

False Start-0-0

Holding-0-0

Sacks Allowed-0.25-0.25

Yards-1.75-1.75

 

I tried to make it easier for you to read.

 

Sigh

 

This has to be a joke account.

Posted
QB rating is the NFL equivalent to RBI's' date=' dude. You can use it as a support statistic, and little more. However, your point is valid, they're comparable players, just don't think Schaub is better than Manning at all. No one is.[/quote']

 

NO

 

its more the equivalent of OPS in baseball

 

and I said Schaub over Brady NOT over Manning

Posted
lol Pro Bowl. The biggest waste of an event ever. I think every all star game is more popular than the Pro Bowl. Probably even the NHL All Star Game.
Posted
http://www.nfl.com/probowl/story?id=09000d5d8155c2fa&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true

 

Definitely some snubs here.

 

Matt Schuab, London Fletcher-Baker, Lousaka Polite.

 

I've seen a number of people get into an uproar about Ray Rice making it over Thomas Jones, Rice is having the better season so its basically homer Jets fans.

 

Thoughts?

 

 

 

 

Schaub? Maybe. London Fletcher? Definitely snubbed. Polite? Are you f***** high or are you testing to make sure people are actually reading your post?

Posted
lol Pro Bowl. The biggest waste of an event ever. I think every all star game is more popular than the Pro Bowl. Probably even the NHL All Star Game.

 

Having it the week before the super bowl is a step up. Im not glorifying it, but hey something to watch instead of nonstop 2 week talk about the super bowl

Posted

I think its safe to say that the players chosen who are going to make the super bowl wont be playing in the pro bowl

 

so IMO its a stupid idea to play it a week before the super bowl

Posted
lol Pro Bowl. The biggest waste of an event ever. I think every all star game is more popular than the Pro Bowl. Probably even the NHL All Star Game.

 

Hey! Hey! Let's not say things we cannot take back. The NHL All Star Game is above all of them.

Posted
Schaub? Maybe. London Fletcher? Definitely snubbed. Polite? Are you f***** high or are you testing to make sure people are actually reading your post?

 

How is Schuab even a "maybe"? He's on a Top 3 passing offense.

 

And you obviously don't know much about Polite if you think its that big of a stretch...

Posted
How is Schuab even a "maybe"? He's on a Top 3 passing offense.

 

And you obviously don't know much about Polite if you think its that big of a stretch...

 

 

You mean Polite the running back with 228 career rushing yards and 0 career running touchdowns?

Posted
How is Schuab even a "maybe"? He's on a Top 3 passing offense.

 

And you obviously don't know much about Polite if you think its that big of a stretch...

 

 

Because Schaub is maybe a top 3. He's behind Manning and Rivers for sure, and he's maybe behind/ahead of Brady. That makes him "maybe" snubbed.

Posted
lol Pro Bowl. The biggest waste of an event ever. I think every all star game is more popular than the Pro Bowl. Probably even the NHL All Star Game.

 

Unfortunately. They should just line-up in shorts and tee shirts. And play tag football.

 

The Pro-Bowl is a time honored joke.

Posted
You mean Polite the running back with 228 career rushing yards and 0 career running touchdowns?

 

No. I mean the Fullback that is 12 and 13 in 3rd & 1 and 4th & 1 situations. The same Fullback that has led the way for Ronnie Brown and a 32 year old Runningback by the name of Ricky Williams... The same Fullback that has been incredible this season and arguably the best blocking Fullback and best overall Fullback this season...

 

That's who I mean.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...