Reddick vs. Anderson

[Dojji]

Meredith "blossomed" for a single year in San Diego, then fell back to earth and has been steadily receding each year since. His WHIP has torpedoed upward and now his ERA is following.

 

If we'd kept him, we would have hated him.

[Rdsxmbnt]

His 05 season included a)pitching in AAAA, b)pitching in an extreme hitters park, and c) a .199 BABIP. He had a solid season but those numbers he put up were never going to be replicated and they never were. He's an average MLB MR, I don't think there was any ruining.

[Dojji]

Average might be a compliment. All of his good years and 1 of his bad ones came in the biggest pitcher's park there is. He's nibbled ever since he left Petco, and towards the end of his Padres tenure even Petco wasn't holding him.

[pootsypop]

honestly if you watched reddick bat during the season while he was called up, you wouldve seen his ability at the plate. almost every at-bat i saw from him he was fouling off a lot of pitches and really working the count well. I think he has great potential, and i heard he has great speed too