Come on, I was a teacher, too. We don't give grades based on expectations... let's see: '21 they won 92 -- 92's an A... '20 they won 24 -- uh, out of 60 -- still only .400; 40%'s an F. But last year the winning percentage was only .568 or 57% rounded up... ok, grade on a curve; only three other students out of 15 in the class had a higher score.
Sorry, I come from a time when All-Stars were chosen based on who actually earned it -- not potential or popularity -- but who had an All-Star season. This ended in the majors when MLB gave the ballots back to the fans, but amateur leagues like Little League on up were mostly based on merit.
Nowadays, our town LL holds All-Star try-outs after the season. Tools are evaluated -- which means the fastest kids with the best arms are always stars -- no matter what kind of Spring they had. Everyone that signs up doesn't get a trophy like in soccer... but there was one infamous case of a player selected for districts after he struck out 20 times in 20 at bats. Had a decent arm, though.