Me, neither. As of now, the potential of young pitching may be the only way the 2026 Red Sox could improve on the squad that opened 2025.
Last year's Opening Day #2, 3 and 4 hitters are or may be gone: Devers, Bregman, Casas.
Contreras replaces Raffy or Tris (if he's not ready). A full year of Anthony should give Boston a boost, but his '25 production - 8 HR, 32 RBI, .859 OPS - isn't much different than Reysnyder, another Red Sox batter who just left - 9 HR, 30 RBI, .838 OPS.
Even if they sign Bregman or Bichette, is the line-up any better? We'll be counting a lot on health and a 21-year-old becoming a superstar.
On the mound, Sonny Gray and Oviedo replace Giolito and Buehler. That's a reasonable wash, with a shot at hubcaps sparkling since Oviedo is still under 30.
But if one or both of the young arms of Early and Tolle solidify the rotation, the Sox could be true contenders (assuming the bullpen doesn't regress too much). That's who they can't trade for Marte...