And that small sample size tells us almost nothing.
But... you still make a good point. It does tell us that many of us are over-reacting every time we lose, and it's easy to blame the worst producing offensive players for those loses. There is NO DOUBT that 1 player alone in isolation doesn't really effect the overall big picture. Now 3 or 4 s***** producing guys, giving us next to nothing offensively, night after night? Yes. We can and should blame them collectively and individually. They flat out need to start hitting, or be given some time to watch.
BUT......
Anybody who watches the Celtics knows by now what a difference a Defensive player can make, simply by watching the D of Markus Smart.
JBJ is much the same. With him, we have perhaps THE BEST mlb outfield. Without him, Beni is average at best in CF, and JDM is somewhat of a liability. I personally think the GAP in CF with Beni vs. JBJ is HUGE!! Often a game changer. So there in lies the conundrum. He needs to sit & watch, but doing so hurts our D big time!
Anyway, it's tough! if JBJ had an option, I would send him down to get right. In fact, I might find an injury he needed work on, with a long rehab assignment in Pawtucket to follow?
I'm a huge JBJ fan, but right now he needs to sit, & work things out. I can deal with the .049% winning percentage difference without him. We will be fine with JDM, but I would put Mookie in CF, Keep Beni in LF, and move JDM to RF.
One thing is for sure, although Beni did ok in CF coming up, he IS NOT a great CF'r!!! He becomes a liability there.