moonslav59

I get the idea of not trading away one of your top 3 offensive, when you then say we need to add offense. Moving Duran to 1B is cheaper than signing one, and it makes room for Anthony in the OF and improves OF D. Having more money can help us sign a better player or another one (3B and 2B or P)

He's a hard one to project. He could hit 30-40 dingers, if he can get 650 PAs. He could hit .725 with 20 HRs. He could get hurt again and give us nothing.

Skubal has one year left and will take an extension much higher than Crochet's. I'm not sure I'd so a trade for him, unless he extends, first. You rarely see those deals anymore. Crochet had 2 years left and was able to be extended at a reasonable rate.

Yup. Nobody seemed to care.

Duran, yes. Abreu is a GG RF'er in a difficult park.

His final OPS was very close to the league average in 2025, as it is.

How about the fact that Manny missed ST'ing time due to 7 grandmothers dying.

Agreed, and Alonso a age 34-35 might outhit Suarez at age 34-35. (Note: Suarez just turned 34, so 2 yrs would be ages 34-35 not 36.) Suarez would be better on D at 1B and would provide the 3B depth we need.

I love Rafaela, but I'd trade him for Greene or even Lodolo straight up, but I think Cincy wants offense. I'm not sure they view Casas, Campbell or Garcia as the offense they need, but I'd add one of them to Rafaela to get Greene. Trading two RHB OF'ers might not look right, but Rafaela is not a good batter and actually has slight reverse splits. We could bring Refsnyder back to bridge to Campbell or Garcia- whichever we keep. Rafaela + Campbell + Clarke for Greene would do it for me. (Keep Garcia- the better defender) LF: Duran- Refsnyder/Garcia CF: Anthony- Garcia (Duran) RF: Abreu-Refsnyder/Garcia (Anthony)

He's older than Story was, but inflation brings him near "Story money." His nice start to 2025 helped, but I think the injury and being a year older makes it about even or worse. Apparently DET offered him $170M/6 last winter, so with inflation and being a year older, I'm guessing $170M/6 is tops and probably not likely. Maybe $150-160M/6 or $130-140M/5. Maybe, he signs for $30M, $30M (opt out after 2) and then $25M. $25M, $20M. That's $130M/5 but with an opt out.

How about signing Okamoto (3B/1B), Suarez (1B/3B), Matz and then trade Wong & Hicks for Murphy and Duran for Lodolo? (Kinda RHB heavy) Is that enough? 1. L Anthony LF 2. R Okamoto 3B 3. L Abreu/ R Refsnyder RF 4. R Suarez 1B 5. L Yoshida DH/ R Murphy DH-C 6. R Story SS 7. R Murphy C/ R Narvaez C 8. L Mayer 2B/ R Romy 2B 9. R Rafaela CF SP: Crochet, Lodolo, Bello, Sandoval, Crawford (AAA: Early, Tolle, Dobbins, Harrison, Perales, Uberstine) RP: Chapman, Whitlock, Slaten, Matz, Weissert, Bernardino, Fitts, Criswell (AAA: Murphy, Sandlin, Wink, Moran, Kelly, Guerrero, I Campbell, Mullins, Drohan, Song)

Yes. I mentioned 1B, because of Mayer, but Mayer can play 2B and with Romy as 2B depth, I'd feel safer that way.

Unless we dump Yoshida's salary, I'm not sure looking for a big bat at DH is the best plan. While I'd love to have Schwarber's bat in our line-up, we really need corner infield or 2B more. One could view Alonso as a DH-first player, but he's a RHB. (He may be about as bad as Casas at 1B defense, so one would DH and one would try to play 1B w/o embarrassing themselves.) RHB Alonso & LHB Schwarber are the two best bats. I doubt we get either one. RHB Suarez (1B/3B) RHB Okamoto (1B/3B/OF) LHB Murakami (1B/3B) R/LHB Jorge Polanco (2B/DH/ 1B???) RHB Bregman (3B) might be players the Sox could obtain. Possible trade options: R/LHB K Marte (2B) RHB Isaac Paredes (3B/1B/2B) RHB Christian Walker (1B & salary dump by HOU) RHB Sean Murphy (C/DH/1B???) RHB Willson Contreras (1B/DH/ emergency C) Next tier FAs: 1B: Hoskins, Naylor, O'Hearn, Bell (Santana/France), 2B: Torres, W Castro, B Lowe, Rengifo, D Moore, SS: Bichette (2B/3B), 3B: Moncada, DH: Ozuna

I'm not sure he's worth that risk, either. I think I'm more interested in 29 year old RHB Okamoto, who K's less. He's also viewed as a plus defender at 1B and could be 3B depth, in case Mayer gets hurt.

I'd put the odds at 1% Houck is non tendered.

If he doesn't get $20AAV all the more reason to sign him. His ability to add 3B depth is something Casas and Campbell can't do. (Maybe Romy can, but we don't want him as our FT 1Bman.) Walker is a great example of a warning on signing these aging players. I'd rather we sign Alonso and or trade for K Marte, but I was addressing the issue with long term deals. Like Walker, Suarez will not get a long term deal, and even 3 years might be a push. $40M/2 might be what gets him to sign. Maybe $38M/2 with a 3rd year option at $15M w a $4M buyout- making it $42M/2 or $55M/3 (team's choice.)

Yes, but $150M/8 to 10 is a lot different than $150M/4 or 5.

All I know is that Perales is pitching.

RHB Eugenio Suarez turns 35 in mid July. He's played over 145 games for 5 straight seasons. In his last 4 seasons, he's had these OPS+: 129 in '22 103 in '23 (kinda scary) 115 in '24 126 in '25 (94 w SEA after trade) 4 year total 118. He's had a dWAR of 0.0 in the same period of time, but he was minus in DRS and OOA in 2015 at 3B. ('22-'24: -8 DRS but +13 OAA.) I'm thinking he'd be a plus at 1B and offer depth at 3B, if Mayer gets hurt. He's a risk, but he seems to be aging well. Maybe he'll take $70M/3? RHP Merrill Kelly just turned 87....errr...I mean 37. That's pretty damn old for a pitcher, and he had an injury in 2024, but he had 33, 30 and 32 in the other 3 seasons since 2022. His ERA+ has been between 104 ('24) to 133 ('23) and sits at a pretty awesome 120 from '22-'25. FIP 3.81. It's hard to project his future and risk potential, but maybe he takes a 2 years deal- maybe $45M/2. Together, those deals total about $45M AAV, which is about how far below the the tax line we are projected for 2026. If we choose to stay under, that would be all we could add, without cutting some salary or trading equal salary amounts. (Duran makes $8M AAV and Campbell $7.5M AAV- Lodolo makes less. Hint-hint.)

Of course, ther risk of failure or steep decline is higher, but at least it's not a 5, 6 year or longer bust.

Alex Speier was on the latest soxprospects.com's podcast and said some encouraging things about the Sox looking to upgrade the top of the rotation with someone better than Gio, while also adding a power bat. He talked about how the Sox could easily have a AAA 5 man rotation of capable 5th starters, and how the Sox are well positioned to make trades with teams looking to rebuild (prospects) or to compete in 2026 (Duran/Abreu or pitching depth.) "Giant question marks:" Casas, Mayer and Campbell. We are no longer "waiting on a prospect," except maybe with pitching. We are waiting for players who already have some experience to "make the next step in their development and where are we going to chose to upgrade from outside the system."

I fully understand your position, and with our record on deals longer that 4 years, I realize the risk involved. I've actually suggested going after two guys, only because they will likely get less than 5 years and maybe even 2-3 years: Merrill Kelly and E Suarez. Now, there is heightened risk with them, because of their ages, but I'm thinking their risks are not any worse than signing a 6-10 year deal with someone younger.

He did end up getting very upset when they would not commit to the option years that led to the trade, and maybe he felt like his "good will" on taking deferments should have been demoted. The whole ending to his Sox time was a big bummer, and there were more to come after him. (There were plenty from before, too.)

When they say $150-200M, is it for 4 years or 10, or what?

No slight intended towards the Jays. They earned their trip to the WS and built a team that was better than I expected, but pretty damn good. I've mentioned how they had 3 SP'ers with 31+ GS. That helps, a lot. Their offense got better was the year went on. Their pen did okay, despite having a questionable closer for most of the season. That being said, they lost 88 games in 2024 and did not make a ton of additions. Looking at 2026, they have more productive players becoming FAs than the Sox do: Bassitt, Bichette, Bieber, Scherzer, Kiner-Falefa, plsu France & Dominguez. A lot will depend on who comes back or who might replace them, but they have a lot of winter questions. SEA made some bold deadline deals and made a great run at the big prize. Their once great rotation kinda struggled, this year, but they still came very close to making the WS. They may lose 3 huge bats: E Suarez, Naylor & Polanco and a real good pen arm in Munoz. They have some big winter needs, too. The Yanks will certainly retool, and they should have Cole back, but we know what counting on returning IL pitchers can amount to. They lose a couple big bats: Bellinger & Grisham, plus a bunch of role players like Weaver, Goldschmidt, Williams, Loaisaga, Hill, Rosario, Slater & Yarboro. It will be interesting to see what their winter budget will be. The Sox lose Bregman and Gio. Refsnyder and Matz had key roles, but not major ones. Wilson, too. Our budget may be our do or die question.