I know you asked about 2022, but since this thread is about 2021, I started with that area, first. I did not go into the fact that we may be sellers at the deadline and how that might affect the 2022 outlook.
I guess we go on the assumption we take the options on Richards, Vaz and Perez, but maybe not Andriese, who would make $3.5M, next year. Assume no on him. . I don't like to go by what we drop in salary, since arb raises can and will be substantial, this winter.
Devers enters his 2nd arb year out of 3.
Renfroe 3 of 4
Plawecki 4 of 4
Brasier 2 of 3
Cordero 2 of 3
and all these players first timers:
Verdugo, Pivetta, Arroyo, Taylor, Brennan & Chavis
I'll assume JD stays at $22M and does not opt out.
Here are my numbers, including the 3 options taken (in Lux $):
25 Sale
22 JD (no opt out or renegotiation)
20 Bogey
17 Eovaldi
15 Price (edit)
10 Richards (option)
7.0 Kike
7.0 Vaz (option)
6.0 Perez (option)
That's a base of $129M
I'm no expert on arbs, but let's assume:
$7M from $4.58M) Devers enters his 2nd arb year out of 3.
$5M (from $3.1M) Renfroe 3 of 4
$2M (from $1.6M) Plawecki 4 of 4
$1.5M (from $1.25M) Brasier 2 of 3
$1.0M (from $800K)Cordero 2 of 3
$4.0M Verdugo, 1 of 3
$3.5M Pivetta, 1 of 3
$2.0M Arroyo, 1 of 3
$1.5M Taylor, 1of 4,
$800K Brennan, 1of 3
$800K Chavis, 1 of 4
The arbs add about $29.5M plus $2.5M for the rest of the 40 man roster and $16M for player benefits and the total before replacing or adding anyone is:
$177M
If we can spend up to the first tax line (assuming it's the same $210M) we will have $33M to spend. If we can spend up to the second line, it's $53M.
I'm not going to name any names except I think maybe we try to bring Barnes back.
The big need areas, to me, are (with projected cost via free agency):
#1-2 SP ($15-30M/yr) Losinng ERod this winter and are adding Sale in 2021. (Could add Houck/Whitlock)
Closer ($10-18M) Losing Barnes (No closer in the system unless Ort turns a miracle)
Set-Up ($5-10M) Losing Ottavino (no clear #2 RP'er in the system)
1B, 2B, OF ($5-20M) Losing Marwin (Duran, Casas, Downs?)
RP'er ($3-7M) Losing Andriese (Bazardo/Seabold/ converted SP'er assuming all SP'er healthy)
That's $38M minimum and maybe $78M maximim. I doubt we spend more than $53M, so we can't get the best at every position of need. More likely, we will plan on in system options to cover 1B, 2B and or CF and go cheap there. We might sign just 2 RP'er not 3. We may sign a #3 SP'er not a #1-2 type, which may depend on how Sale looks, this year.
We have a great chance to improve upon this current roster.
Barnes will be tough to extend, re-sign or replace.
Ottavino is pitching to his contract value, so that should be about push.
ERod looked very hard to replace before seeing him in 2021, so far. We still need to fill his slot, but right now, he's pitching like a 4 or 5 (maybe even a 6), but to improve, we need to replace him with a 1 or 2, IMO. That should be our top priority, and if we only have $33M to spend, we might spend $20M on a solid #2 or very old ace and $13M on a good but not great closer and count on our system to fill out the depth issues.
It should be an interesting winter.
(edited numbers and comments to reflect Price's $15M I forgot to include.)