We may be losing some top batters, but I have to think we will be adding some good bats to replace the ones we lose. We are also losing some pathetic bats, too, and it is hard to imagine almost anyone we get not doing better than Dalbec, JBJ, Duran, Plawecki and others.
Here is a breakdown of our OPS in order of most PAs in 2022. The ones in red may not get any or much fewer PAs in 2023/ the ones in Blue should get more PAs in 2023:
.732 Dugo
.833 Bogey
.879 Devers
.790 JD
.629 Kike (hopefully at more like 2021 numbers than 2022
.737 Story (hopefully at a better OPS than 2022
.652 Dalbec
.759 Vaz
.736 Arroyo
.578 JBJ
.697 Cordero
.672 Pham
.645 Duran
.881 Refsnyder
.574 Plawecki
.877 McGuire
.766 Casas
.585 Wong (needs to improve or be replaced)
.631 Hosmer
.322 Sanchez, .427 Downs, .697 Almonte, .782 JDavis, .596 Chang, .000 Arauz & Shaw (200+ PAs from these last scrubs, alone)
Bogey, JD and Vaz (especially for a catcher) will not be easy to replace, offensively, but we may be able to improve on defense with there replacements and make up the offense with blue players.
It's 1545 PAs lost by Bogey, JD and Vaz, but the total of bad offensive players lost or likely sharply declining in playing time is actually a higher number (over 1700):
353 Dalbec .652
290 JBJ .578
275 Cordero .697
235 Pham .672
223 Duran .645
175 Plawecki .574
200+ from scrubs
Note: I make this same point every winter, and the following year has a new list of players doing poorly, so I'm not saying it is a cinch we replace all the bed OPS guys with better ones, but my point still stands. We have opportunities to improve in many areas without spending or making any major moves. Guys like Kike, Story, Casas, Refsnyder, McGuire, Arroyo and Dugo might show improvement enough to take up more than enough slack, but we need to not lose much at SS, DH and C.