Nobody is even close to being satisfied, but some seem to gravitate towards gloom & doom, more than others.
My hopes have certainly dropped from where they were after the opening series, but they are not dashed.
Yes, part of the reason they are not dashed has to do with how almost every AL team has some serious issues, too, and just haven't been bitten by them, yet, but also because I still see a lot of promise in our players. Then, there are the returning players added promise.
Perhaps, my biggest reason for promise may surprise some, here. It is actually the starting rotation. As badly as they have done, we are still just 1GB the WC. It appears we don't need greatness from the rotation- just some sort return to close to norms by most of them.
I could end up with dozens of eggs on my face, but I refuse to believe these guys are and will continue to be as bad as they have been.
How many more wins would we have, right now, had Sale (8.22), Kluber (6.75), Bello (6.57) and Whitlock (6.19) just been at 5.00, let alone near their career norms? Had Pivetta been at his 4.47 ERA, since joining the Sox, instead of 5.11, do we have one more win? How about Houck at 4.50?
My point is, we may not need these guys to be at 3.00 to 3.75 to have a good chance at advancing through a round or two of the playoffs. I know there might not be any signs these guys can or will turn things around, but is it unreasonable to think 3-4 of these guys might give us these ERAs over the remainder of the season (not counting their starts to the season:)
Houck 4.10 (3.50 career ERA as a SP in 25 GS, including 2023.)
Whitlock 4.20 (4.15 ERA as a SP'er, last season in 9 GS) assuming healthy
Sale 4.30 (4.09 ERA from 2019-2022)
Bello 4.40 (3.83 last 11 games in 2022)
Pivetta 4.50 (4.47 ERA w Sox from 2020-2022)
Kluber 4.60 (4.34 in 2022/ 4.36 after injury in 55 GS)
Paxton 4.75 ???
Is it absurd to actually expect 3-4 of these happening?