The JBJ trade sucked. I said it then, and still think it was horrific.
I don't judge GMs on one deal, and besides, Bloom was the one who signed Renfroe for just $3M.
The overall grade on Bloom's moves is still TBD, because so many involved prospects coming to us, including Wink, Wong and others, but as of now, I would grade It at B- or better.
His main task was to rebuild the farm, and that is an even bigger TBD, but as of now, it looks pretty damn good. We went from bottom 5 or 10 to top 5 or 10.
The budget is in better shape, should JH ever decide to spend again. (BTW, JH has had 2-3 year stretches in the past with very little new spending, so it might happen, again.)
If you want to focus on the worst move every GM has made to judge them, there would be nobody left to take Bloom's place.