Good OP and good discussion, everyone. Thanks. I exclude the rant against Cora, which is just silly as well as ignorant. .
I was all for trading Duran for a #2 starter, but the guy SD is offering ain't a #2. Plus he's a rental???!!!
Right now Duran leads the Sox in games played, total bases, and runs scored. He is 4th in rbi's. All good. However, his OPS vs lefties is a lousy .567, which is lower than Gonzalez, Bregman, Ref, Narvaez, Rafaela, Yoshida, Abreu, and Anthony.
As it turns out, the Sox team OPS vs lefties is .761 and .742 vs righties. And the Sox face righty pitchers more than twice as often (2501 AB's vs 1101). That's why Rafaela plays 2b against righty starters--so that Cora can get 3 lefty bats in the outfield plus another as DH and another at 1b. I hasten to add that Rafaela, Duran, and Anthony play almost every game, which makes Abreu the odd man out.
The top 9 WAR's on the team are Rafaela 4.0, Narvaez 3.1, Bregman 3.0, Duran 2.8, Abreu 2.4, Story 2.1, Anthony 1.7 (in just 40 freaking games), Ref 1.2, and Gonzalez 1.0. Then come Toro 0.3, Hamilton 0.3,and Mayer 0.2.
And this. So far this season the Sox starters have pitched 47 quality starts, 4th most in MLB. 41 of the 47 are by the 5 current starters: Crochet 14, Bello 10, Giolito 9, Buehler 6, and Fitts 2 (in 9 starts). Cease has 6 quality starts--same as Buehler--in 21 starts. No way, no how is he a #2 starter.