A fair point. However, of the four WS teams, y far the best was 2018, and that year Bogey’s DWAR was -1.0 among the lowest in MLB.
When I launched that tirade, my point was mostly that the Sox tend to retain infielders who can hit, especially SS’s, and to dump excellent fielding SS’s who can’t hit. Two who come to mind are Alex Gonzalez and Julio iglesias. Nomar and Bogey, both good hitting SS’s, stayed awhile.
Me, I prefer brilliant fielding SS’s, whether or not they can hit. Hitting is no doubt more important, but great fielding is much more fun to watch.