Reddick wasn't appreciated here because he is a defensive liability especailly in right field in Fenway. Did you see his play the last time at Fenway when he was with the A's. I don't think much of Cherrington as a GM but he gets a pass on this one. The Sox couldn't foresee that they would have 7 outfielders on the DL at the same time. Yes Reddick is putting up some good numbers now but he is streaky. He did so with the Sox. Given his past history and his defensive shortcomings, I don't think it was a bad deal