It isn't if we are going to pitch next year as we have down the stretch this year. If its going to be ERod and pray for 4 days of rain, suddenly an elite defender in CF becomes less valuable compared to a good one with a decent bat. Heck we don't really even know if ERod can repeat 2019 in 2020. We are awash in pitching issues and when a team is awash in pitching issues suddenly these guys that can produce 1 for 25 and 2 for 50 slumps at the plate have a harder time making the case for an elite glove even in CF. JBJ is not and never has been a reliable hitter at the plate or even close to a reliable hitter at the plate and I don't see a way at this point for a guy that has been doing this for a looooooooooong time to change his ways.
I would willingly pay 6 per maybe 7 for JBJ and not a dime more. He might not accept that. But that is all I would be offering. 6 is closer to what he might be worth at this point.
Then again since nobody can really say or even guess where MLB pitching is going thanks to all of their machinations, maybe keeping the everyday player composition of the team what it is makes as much sense as anything.