I don't think you can look at any of the more recent pitching moves as anything more than trying to throw stuff against the wall to see what would stick with the usual results. Some of it sticks a little, some of it does not stick at all...little of it sticks very much.
As for moves made before this period of garage picking, I always thought that dice for example was another of these PR motivated personnel moves, not trying to pander to some Japanese fan base but pandering instead to the interests of fans that enjoy sizzle, are attracted to the novel. the unique move. The dice package included the posting fee, an interpreter, the limousine service built into the contract, all of that extra ******** that made him an "interesting" choice. Sox management hoped we would ohh and ahh over the Sox far reaching, outside of the box, process for finding pitchers that would slot into the top of the rotation. Yea' that worked!
I thought Lackey was another sizzle move. Lets go right to the top of the list of FA pitchers in this given year and take the guy that is there whether he is right for us or not. I would have thought that both of those pitching moves, particularly Lackey were moves that Bill James would not have liked thinking about recent comments about James and his lack of involvement in recent personnel moves. Not sure how much input James would have had regarding dice but I don't think he would have liked bringing Lackey here at all.