My 3rd bat has to have great power AND good-to-great discipline (i.e. 340+ OBP). Devers is a natural 3rd bat in my book. Also his speed is good. He can even steal bases at times if needed.
Renfore is a great fit at the 5th slot in my lineup. Lot of PWR with competitive BA but not great discipline.
Verdugo is a natural leadoff bat. He has speed, has a good jump to steal bases, and has great BA and OBP with a plus; he has pop as well. He could become a super star and close to what a five-tool-player is in the near future —Mookie-type of player.
Xander is a perfect fit at the 2nd slot in my book. I want someone at my 2nd slot with the best BA, period. I want someone who hits and hits a lot. Xander is very good at that. Also, the second slot needs good speed, not great but good enough to run 2 bases without major problems. Xander can do that.
JD is a natural 4th bat. Elite PWR, with good-to-great BA and discipline. Thing is JD has it all regarding the bat and he is not that slow.