I don't remember the last time a CY Young race was so all over the place. Weaver leads in strikeouts, Buchholz leads ERA, Sabathia leads in wins, Felix leads IP, and Cliff Lee WHIP.
No player truly stands out-- for every player with strengths, they have weaknesses. Felix's 8 wins ruin his chances, Price's 1.26 WHIP can't help his case, Buchholz's IP, and Cliff Lee lack of quality starts show why he's low on wins. Cahill could have a shot, but most people have never even heard of the guy, including myself.
If I had to bet, I'd put my money on Price. He's leading a group of elite young pitchers to the playoffs. He's got a ton of wins, his ERA is great, and everyone knows who he is. Plus, the other two guys I'd put money on, Cliff Lee hasn't been great since going to Texas, and Felix just has half the wins Price has.