They need that no.3 starter. They never replaced Buchholz this year. Nor Dice-K, for that matter.
Instead, they kept throwing Lackey, Wakefield and Miller out there ad nauseam. Lackey and Wakefield are bad. They have to disappear off-season. Miller gets an incomplete--he should be in AAA--and would have been there with an option available.
Their big mistake was blindly throwing those three guys out there start after start, and then leaving Aceves-- a better pitcher--to mop up after these guys had crapped the bed. That must have frustrated the hitters--as Papi has implied. And they still are throwing those same guys out there (less Miller)--with the playoffs on the line!
Sure, they had no control over Buchholz and Dice-K going down. But the management didn't replace them properly in the rotation. They overestimated their pitching depth.