On Scutaro, I suspect somebody in the FO woke up one day and said: Scutaro's a year older at 36, and is an average SS. He might be a little worse this year, and we're paying him $6mil. We have decent replcement in Aviles who is a better hitter, younger, and we're paying him less. We also have a kid we're paying $2mil to play in AAA who is all-world defensively. Colorado calls us up and says we'll take Scutaro off your hands, pay his salary, and put him at 2B. So they effectively dropped Papi's salary $6mil by making the deal. Sounds like a good business decision to me.
Seems like the Red Sox have had a persistent problem in recent years of holding onto aging, over-the-hill players and blocking younger players. I'm thinking of catcher, pitching and RF. Not to mention the Ellsbury fiasco. In that sense, the Scutaro move is a breath of fresh air. They got younger and cheaper.