Santana has a long track record of not being very good. Renfroe had a few good years in SD and then sucked last year. I’d bet on Renfroe. At the minimum, he’s a good platoon bat against LHP.
No. It’s a long season. Not every game is the 7th game of the WS. Andriese should be able to get outs. He’s on the roster for a reason. Bloom can take him off if he stinks.