I don't want to poke any holes in Pedroia, but I'm sorry, no, I disagree. Schilling's postseason heroics carried us through 2 World Series rings. Pedroia's been on hand for 2 as well, and he has featured prominently in them, but I've never felt like Pedroia put us over the top in any of them. Great player to have, emotional leader of the team, all that stuff is true, but the magnitude of what Shilling accomplished and the fact that he was able to carry his weight again in 2007 at the end of his career, that stuff speaks volumes to me.