And that's the real problem, and why actually getting more playing time on a team like the Red Sox was a bit of a pipe dream.
Actually when Nixon went down he got it done just fine, it's just that after they signed Drew -- and believe me, they should definitely have signed Drew -- Wily Mo had no plac left to play.
How many chances has he really gotten to just get in there and play long term? even with the Nationals he was getting platoon at bats or less other than one stint of regular playing time at the end of 2007 in which he was effective.
When the guy's gotten to play, I mean really play more than one or two games in a row, he's been an effective hitter. It's because we couldn't give him that that we gave up on him -- that and the whole fielding thing of course.
Except that in 2006 he hit .301/.349/.489, with the Sox, because he got regular at bats, but of course that doesn't help your argument so you're inclined to forget it.
Yeah, because Schilling, Beckett, Wakefield and Lester didn't pitch at all that year, and Clement and Wells didn't win 28 games between them the prior season.
We had no way of knowing that Clement's shoulder resembled Salisbury steak or that Wells would take a line drive off the knee early in the season. You can't judge transactions like that off that level of hindsight. Our best pitching prospect got FREAKING CANCER. So many things just plain went to hell that year that I think you just have to give Theo an overall mulligan, especially given the results the following year.