You guys obviously don't do your research. You are 100% wrong. Jones has actually struck almost exactly the same amount as JD Drew per at-bat. Believe it or not, if you did your research you would have realized this. Here are the stats.
JD Drew has had 3306 at bats and 716 strike outs. Crunch the numbers and that equals a strike out every 4.6 at-bats. Now Andrew Jones has had 6010 at-bats and 1310 strike outs. That means a strike out every 4.6 at-bats. What you guys failed to realize is that in the 3 season JD Drew managed to play more than 130 games, he struck out 100+ times. There goes that argument. And just to give you some insite, Manny Ramirez has averaged a strike out every 4.5. Strike out rates are overated.
I can see your next argument coming. You lost the strike out, so now your going to try to connect it to DP. Yes Andrew Jones has grounded into more DP per atbat than JD Drew, but its a bit misleading. If you really want to base your argument on that, then I guess Manny Ramirez really sucks, because Manny has grounded into a DP every 33.8 atbats, Andrew Jones once every 40.8 atbats.
If you just look at the stats, Jones has been better. Period. Right now Jones and JD Drew have the exact same career SLG at .503. I have already stated that they strike out about the same frequency. Drew holds the higher OBP and BA, granted Jones .345 OBP ain't to shabby. JD holds a slightly higher OPS, .894:848. Jones has 9 gold gloves, JD none. Jones hasn't ever been on the DL and has played at least 153 games each season. He has actually put together great season after season and has been consistant. Thats what is really important. Consistancy, and Jones has been consistant, JD hasn't.
Potential is an overrated and overused term. The reality is, Drew has had 9 season to reach his potential, but hasn't. He is 31 and still hasn't reached his potential. On top of that, Drew has a high Potential for injuries. Yes, you can use potential for the negatives too, most of you guys just ignore that. The fact is, Jones has year in year out played to his potential and is consistantly one of the top OF offensively and defensively.
And I have already states how poorly Drew has done in the playoffs. In 7 series, 27 games, Drew has posted a .233BA, .320OBP, .349SLG, 3HR, 6 RBI, 11BB. Thats aweful.
Jones, however, in 17 series, 75 games, has posted a .273BA, .364OBP, .433SLG, 10HR, 33RBI, 34BB. Much better numbers. Also, in case you didn't notice, that means Jones posted a higher BA and OBP in the playoffs than his career numbers. That kinda seems "clutch" to those who love that word, ya?
Just look at their stats. I've put up charts on Jones and Drews career numbers and career playoff stats. Just take a look. Its hard to ignore the fact that Jones has put up 11 years of great numbers while Drew hasn't. Thats fact.
Just check the stats I attached.