VMart leaked it IIRC, I remember him answering questions about that pretty honestly a few months back.
There is no strategic plant, the sox were just starting negotiations. VMart has now surpassed Posada as the #2 offensive catcher in the game behind Mauer. He is going to get paid like it. And right now, seeing as he is planning on being paid as a catcher, the sox are going to have to dish out cash and yrs to the guy, cause he is gonna get some serious offers. I know most of you guys think the sox dont have any competition here. But just look at the average catcher line for 2010. The average OPS in the bigs out of the catcher position is .699. VMart was in the .850 range and can switch hit. Just because the Yankees are not going to be in the running doesnt mean the sox are locks to retain him. He is in the driver's seat right now in terms of negotiations. He's 31 (not too old), can switch hit, can hit in the middle of the lineup and is the second best offensive catcher in baseball at a position that sees HORRIBLE offensive production.
Now there is what is reasonable and what is foolish. If some team that is close thinks that VMart can be the missing piece of the puzzle for the next 3-4 yrs and doesnt mind having an albatross at the backend, might offer him 5-6 yrs. But with catchers on the wrong side of 30, 4 yr deals are appropriate. I think a good offer is what Posada got, at 4yrs $52 mil. BUT, you need to see how the landscape has changed since Posada signed his deal. Joe Mauer also signed a big time contract, and if VMart looks at that contract as a trendsetter for elite offensive production from the C position, then his price just went up.
Think about that. Mauer signed for $23 million per yr. That is $9 million per yr more than Posada and now Martinez has surpassed him. Would it be unreasonable, in the mind of VMart to think that he should meet halfway between Posada and Mauer? Maybe in the $18 mil range? Who knows, but the fact is, the sox lose all leverage 15 days after the WS. If they don't re-up him, I have a strong feeling that he gets an offer he cannot refuse