We have to move Phelps into the rotation. We also must move up either Warren or Mitchell into the other starters role. I know Girardi gave Garcia the dreaded vote of confidence, but the guy doesnt have the movement nor the velocity he had last season. He's sitting mid 80s right now, where he was sitting 88-89 last yr. Also, his splitter has been total s*** and he just cannot survive without all his pitches going for him since he is such a pus-baller. Might be time to just cut your losses.
Hughes never refined his game thanks to a myriad of injuries, poor work ethic, and ever changing roles. This has left him as a guy who pitches like he's throwing 96 while actually throwing 91. He needs to go back to the pen, amp up the velo in shorter stints and become an effective swing man for this team. We need him to assume David Phelps' role.
In terms of Phelps, this kid has the stuff to be a big leaguer. Throws 4 pitches for strikes, can cut, run and ride his fastball to spots and goes right after hitters. I learned more from his Boston appearance than his prior ones because he didnt have all his stuff, but his approach never changed. Attack, attack, attack. He throws like he's a 10 yr vet as a rookie and he should be rewarded as such. He isnt going to be confused with an ace, and never will be. But he throws like a younger Jake Westbrook, a guy capable of throwing 7-8 innings with good pitch counts and getting a lot of weak hacks on pitchers pitches. He wont be a 10 K a game guy, but he should be able to make the transition. Hell, he's been throwing near starts for the Yanks piggybacking Hughes or Garcia. Time to remove one of them from the equation.