So based upon 3 partial seasons, he is a dominant force to be reckoned with? And obviously ERA is the best stat for pitchers? Cmon man. Consistency would be appreciated. Buchholz threw well, when he was healthy. Thing is, he is never healthy and he is coming back from a spinal fracture. He's had to alter his motion and with it, he's lost velocity. That lost velocity has taken away his capacity to put hitter away and he is subsequently required to get into long counts and get hit harder than previous.
And for those who think that he "always starts a season poorly", his career ERA in April is 3.83. It is his second worst month behind July for some reason, but he is not epically bad. Buch's ERA is 8.87, WHIP is nearly 2, his K rate is below 4.5, and his K/BB is 1.1. Guys, that is absolutely f***ing abysmal.
For comparison, would anyone argue that Phil Hughes has sucked thus far this yr? I wouldnt, hell, I want him out of the rotation. And his ERA (7.88), WHIP (1.88), K rate (9.6) and K/BB (2.8) are all SIGNIFICANTLY better. But Hughes sucks and Buchholz is just a little "rusty". Now, he might end up miraculously righting the ship and getting back to his shortened season career high of dominance. But I think it is pretty likely that he doesnt get there this season at least.
Also, the "rusty" idea is assinine as well. He had an entire spring training and has had a full month of starting. He's 2 months into throwing against big league competition after his return from last yrs injury. He's not rusty, he sucks balls right now