Cherington isnt the problem. This team is run by Lucchino and he effectively is the GM with Cherington as the buffer. The problems start there and permeate through. They had the opportunity to move Beckett in the off-season if he is truly the root of the problem since he was coming off a dominant season and is signed rather cheaply for ace pay. They didnt have much room with Youkilis since he was injured most of the yr, put up a horrible season and finished the yr on the OR table.
In the end, the sox dont have much money coming off the books next yr. The only big contract that will come off is Ortiz, and the way he is hitting, you might not want his bat to go elsewhere. The sox need what every team needs right now, and that is starting pitching and bullpen. Thing is, with the extra wild card, sellers will be fewer and further between and the prices will be higher.
Also, Buchholz needs to be demoted. I said it last week and you guys thought I was crazy. He made his hay with a 94mph fastball on average. His location has never been pinpoint, but with his movement he was able to generate weak hacks and keep the ball on the ground. Well, teams are teeing off on hin, which has caused him to nibble and walk guys. Now, he is all messed up. They need to DL him, call it shoulder weakness, have him throw in rehab games and then promote him when his heat is back. Otherwise, he is a waste