Here's the issue with Garza. He has the chops, he has the experience and he has been a #2 on a world series team. Here are the two issues with Garza.
1. The Cubs gave up A TON of talent for him. Now, that talent looks like a dud, but at the time, Archer and Lee were very highly touted prospects and Chirinos was a blocked 26 yr old catcher with a ton of talent. The Cubs got the better end of the deal, no doubt, but if they are just going to turn around and deal Garza, they need to get a similar prospect haul.
2. Garza is having a VERY deceiving season. Last yr, he went to the Cubs and dominated to a level he hadnt shown before. K rate near 9, walk rate at a career low, he halved his HR rate and gave nearly 200IP. This yr, the K rate is still high, the walk rate is higher than his career average, the HR rate is back up, but his pitch counts and durability is trending poorly. Almost like he is going for the K so much that he cannot stay in games. His velo is fine, so stuff isnt an issue.
Going through his starts, May seems to be the reason for his diminished numbers. Maybe he turns it around in June, who knows, but in May, he averaged less than 5IP per start and pitched to a 6+ERA. If he comes back and shows the durability he showed in April (6.5IP per start), then you got me. Maybe we get him anyway and see if he can do it again, but he has had a sudden wild streak mixed in with a sudden rise in taters, I'd want to see more before emptying the farm for him
Another interesting trade proposal would include one of the pitchers from our current roster. Ivan Nova won 16 games last yr, and the big knock on him was that he couldnt K people. Now he is striking people out in droves, but cannot seem to get soft contact. The Yankees need him to be locking down the #3 slot and he's currently pitching like a call-up in need of a send down. Also, Phil Hughes has shown similar flashes of brilliance with a high K rate, but has been pounded enough to make his spot a little tenuous. Maybe a Nova, Warren, Joseph deal for Garza gets it done