I don't think Middlebrooks is progressing the way you want him to, though. In order for him to succeed in the bigs, he either needs to make more contact, walk more, or hit more balls out of the park/more extra base hits. He had a "breakout" 2012 in 286PA's, but his BABIP was .335. We knew that wasn't sustainable. Hence, he'd need to show improvements in his plate discipline. Well, he didn't make the strides you had hoped. His walk percentage went up slightly by 0.8%, yet his K rate went up by nearly 2%. Had his BABIP plummeted but the K rate dropped or the walk rate rose significantly, then you can say he had back luck. What you are seeing here is more of a bad approach. My guess is the sox will give him a shot for now, but I wouldn't be surprised in the least to see him moved and Drew re-signed. I don't think the reviews have been all that rave about Bogaerts as a SS also.