cp, there is plenty to say he is not an asset defensively. The problem you have right now is that your elite defender in CF isn't hitting enough to justify his starting spot. You are a vastly better defensive team with the B's out there than with Beni in CF and JD in LF. Beni is not a good CFer. JD is a terrible LFer. But if that alternative is having top notch defense and basically a pitcher batting in you lineup, then you need to do it to justify the space. The sox OF has Royals circa 2015 level defensive potential, but that team also had solid offensive production from Gordon and Cain while rotating players through RF, which is admittedly a far less demanding or important defensive position than CF. I am intrigued as to how this plays out. The sox IF defense is awful, so the OF defense was trying to balance out the runs they are losing on the infield. If the OF defense is rough aside from Betts, then you're looking at more lost runs but more run production.