You conveniently forgot Ellsbury, too. That is the reason why this spending spree can be supplemented with our farm. We will need to re-up Lemahieu or be willing to move on from him, which I bet we aren't willing to do. Paxton is gonna go to market, bet on that. He will have a QO attached, but whatever. Tanaka might be willing to sign on for less than what he is making now, probably considerably less unless he puts up an ace type season in 2020. But having Cole at the top of this rotation allows us to take some risks with the back end of the rotation. Let's say Paxton and Tanaka move on, the Yanks would have a hell of a top 2 in Cole and Severino. German would probably be the #3 as his admin suspension isn't going to be into 2021 (likely to be something like the first 15 games of 2020 since he missed so much at the back end of 2019). 2020 would give us the opportunity to see if Montgomery is healthy. If he is, he is a fine #4/5 starter. It would give us a year to groom a #4/5 starter at the back end. Will we be as dangerous, probably not, but still, a playoff rotation that goes Cole-Sevy-German-??(maybe JMont) is still better than what we had this past year.
The contracts coming off would be Ellsbury, Tanaka, Gardner, Happ, Paxton, Lemahieu. That's $97.8 mil. By 2021, the only guy we would absolutely need is Lemahieu. Assume he signs on around the $20 mil mark in AAV, then that will allow for $77.8 mil of new money. Some of that will go to arb costs (Judge, Sanchez, Montgomery for year 2, German, Torres, Andujar, Voit for year 1 of arb) but as none of these are final year tallies, my bet is we only see about $30 mil in increases, which might actually see us fall below the lux tax limit. If that doesn't really matter to Steiny and he wants to win, that's another $40 mil or so we could use to bolster the back end of the rotation