The Yankees have anywhere from the #3-5 farm system in all of baseball and the deepest pitching farm to boot (bottom 3rd in offensive players). The sox sit in the #11 range across the board with one of the weaker pitching farms you will find. The Yankees not only closed the gap, but grabbed hold and jumped past them.
Plus if you want to consider prospects in the majors, consider Wang as the #2 CY guy and Cano as the All star 2b, and Melky vs Paps as all star and the rest being okay as rookies and I think you are rather even in the pros.
The sox system has no pitching ready for the bigs without rushing anyone. The predicament arises as well with the lack of a major league bullpen to any degree and you have the vortex that created Hansen and MDC's collapse last yr. Hansen should have gone to A ball out of college in 05. He should have been in AA last yr and should be in AAA this yr (like a certain other closer in the yankee system, JB Cox). MDC went from a poor single A showing in 04 to a major league debut in 05. MDC should be setting up Hansen in Pawtucket this yr. Instead, Hansen is likely to be closing for a short while in AAA and will eventually be called up when the pile of dogshit they acquired for the pen shows its true stuff.
Gom, after years of the yankees just completely raping their farm, they are doing things right. We have rushed exactly one player in the past few yrs (melky in 05), and he ended up getting set straight last yr. We have had some of the best pitching talent in our minors, and with all of our pitching woes, we easily could have rushed them. Last season, when Chacon sucked and Wright was nothing more than a 4 inning pitcher, we could easily have called on Hughes or Clippard. When Farns went down or Sturtze got hurt, we easily could have rushed Cox to the majors. But we didnt. We filled the need from what we had an kept the kids way from the majors. It has been to their benefit. We essentially have gone into every season with all spots filled and if they blew up, we'd go outside the org. Well now, the kids are ready. The time has come, and we didnt rush them. Now we have a spot for them too.
For the sox, the pen is incomplete. Pineiro is a horrible choice for closer. Donnelly is declining, Romero is awful, Timlin exploded last yr, and Tavares out of the pen was useless. MDC might be ready to step up, Hansen is not. What happens if May comes and Donnelly's and JC's era total 2 touchdowns with the extra points? They rush Cox and Bard up to the majors or bring up the perpetually screwed up Hansen. This will continue to vortex of ruining players. The only guy they got right was Papelbon. He dominated at all levels and made the jump from AA-AAA-MLB in a year. Lester had misleading stats and should have never been called up last yr for his own good (1.46 WHIP and greater than a half a walk per inning in AAA). Granted, the cancer would have been found regardless, but this kid's development needed fine tuning. Something that rushing him through a lackluster AAA season was not gonna get him.
Overall Gom, the sox are creating a perpetual void for their relief prospects to fall into. Fill the pen with s***. Be surprised when the s*** stinks. Rush kids past valuable developmental levels. Be surprised when they turn to s***. Draft more rookie relievers. Lather, Rinse, Repeat. Finally, the yankees did something right with highly regarded prospects. Hopefully it works. But it wont be on the ownership if they dont.