it isnt perfect, we know that. At the same time, scouting seems to have gotten a whole lot better. And in the current scheme, the yankees can flex their financial muscle in the draft, something they didnt do back in the old days. If we get 13 picks before round 3, you can bet a good amount of those guys turn out to be major leaguers. Just take a look at our drafts from the past few yrs...
2004-
1st- Hughes
1st-comp- Poterson
1st-comp- Marquez
2nd- Brett Smith
3rd- Christian Garcia
Poterson is out of the yankee system. Brett Smith struggled in A+ and AA ball and looks like he wont make the bigs. Garcia had TJ surgery but is still a top yankee prospect. Marquez pitched well in AA and should be in AAA next yr. Hughes is a major leaguer.
Other picks of note in 2004: Michael Dunn, pick #999- the only other guy on the list still considered a prospect (now a lefty starting pitcher)
Of those top 5 picks, 1 was a great pick, and 2 of them are still considered good picks.
2005-
1st round- CJ Henry
2nd Round- JB Cox
3rd Round- Brent Gardner
Henry was a bust, but it got us Bobby Abreu, so that is kinda moot. JB Cox would have been in our bullpen this yr had he not had TJ surgery. I expect him to be a major leaguer this upcoming yr. Brett Gardner is a small speedster who will start in AAA this yr. Of the top 3, 2 have a solid chance of making the majors this upcoming yr, with one (Cox) having the potential to be a reliable player.
Other notables- Austin Jackson (8th round), and Alan Horne (11th). Both of these guys are consider top prospects in their respective positions. Horne could be a Yankee in 08 and Jackson has the potential to be as well.
2006
1st round- Ian Kennedy
1st round comp- Joba Chamberlain
3rd round- Zach McCallister
Kennedy and Chamberlain are in the bigs and McCallister is considered one of the best lower level pitching prospects in our system (even though he struggled with fatigue late).
Other notables: Betances, Kontos, Melancon, McCutchen, Patterson, Robertson.
Once again, of the top 3 picks, no strikeouts yet. And the depth of that draft was pretty astounding.
This isnt as much the crapshoot of old when the best players got taken in the order of their ability. Just look above for the examples. Betances was considered a top 10 pick, but fell to the 8th round due to salary demands. Melancon was considered 1st round talent, but fell due to injury concerns and salary demands. Robertson was a top 2 round pick but fell because he was a draft eligible sophomore with 2 yrs of college to bargain with.
Other guys like Kontos and McCutchen were nabbed by shrewd scouting.