I love Paps, and I think he probably deserves it right now, but the fact is, the voters shy away from two things with CY Young winners: rookies and relief pitchers. He is both. If Liriano continues this, I still think it will be a close race between he, Halladay, Santana, and possibly another, like one of the Detroit pitchers, all of them have been good, if one stands out, he could win.