Who cares what Edgar Renteria is doing now? HE STUNK for us. My point was there was no accurate quantification for what moving to a Baseball Crazed city like Boston in the AL would be like for Renteria. I heard rumblings when he first left St. Louis from the manager..Larussa, who said that he wouldn't be able to hack it in Boston.. and he was right. But looking solely at numbers..he should have FLOURISHED in a hitters park like Fenway..why didn't he? Please, give me a formula to figure out the downward spiral Edgar Renteria took last year in a Boston uni. in a hitters park(PF, I am sure you are familiar with this lovely sabre stat)..hitting in front of the best #3 and #4 hitter combo in Baseball(By FAR).... Please, you are losing this argument--and not by a small margin.
Nobody is saying sabremetrics are not important--and useful.. What we are saying is that you cannot figure out everything in baseball 100% accurately taking ONLY satistics into account.