So why do you think Youk will be one of the worst 1B in the game? He doesn't hit for much power, but gets on base alot, which is what this team needs with guys like Manny, Papi, Tek on the team.
Maybe he isn't the greatest defensively (but he sure can't be worse than Millar), but since when does everyone think you need this great defensive player at first? Up until a few years ago, teams put their old, slow guys at first. I remember watching guys like Pete Rose, in his 40's, play first base for the Reds, and no one batted an eye.