If you haven't noticed the Sox have a pop gun lineup without Manny. When Pedroia doesn't hit, they don't score. Ortiz rarely gets challenged with the fastball anymore, and no manager in his right mind would let his pitcher challenge him. He is the one legitimate gamebreaking offensive player in the lineup. Youk is a great offensive player and Bay has been solid, but Manny and Ortiz were a wrecking crew. When one was hot he carried the team. When they were both hot, they destroyed the opposing pitchers. Their presence in the middle of the lineup made everyone in front of them and behind them better. Pitchers couldn't work around them because they could n't put them both on. Now, it is much easier to work around just one of them. They are not exactly stacked with guys with 40+ HR potential. In fact, with the exception of Bay (and he's a long shot) there is no one in the lineup with 40 HR capability. Ortiz is not replaceable, and neither was Manny's bat, if you haven't noticed. Manny had to go, because just shut it down. His bat hasn't been replaced, no matter how much Bay has pleasantly surprised us.