You can't compare Salty to the situation with Crawford or Dice K or 2009/2010 Ortiz. They are all proven ML performers. Salty is not. Other than the fact that he is large, I don't think he has any major tools. Also, he has terrible instincts. I don't think you can teach or learn that. We might survove the season with him at catcher, but why take the chance if there are better alternatives.